- English translation
An unlucky person stays unlucky, even with a lantern hung over his head.
- Literal wording
The luckless one is luckless, even if they hang a lantern on his head.
- Meaning and lesson
The saying expresses a fatalistic view that some people are simply marked by bad fortune. No outside aid, illumination, or advantage placed upon them will change the outcome, because their ill luck clings to them wherever they go.
In practice it is a resigned or wry comment when repeated efforts to help someone keep failing. The speaker suggests that the trouble does not come from a lack of resources or guidance, but from a deeper, persistent misfortune; it is not advice about effort or perseverance.
- When it is used
Use it about someone whose run of misfortune keeps returning despite help, opportunity, or improved circumstances. It can be a rueful remark about oneself or a judgment about another person; aimed at others, it can sound hurtful, as if writing them off as hopeless.
- Register
- colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: An unlucky person stays unlucky, even with a lantern hung over his head.