- English translation
Do you expect a human memory to work like a written ledger?
- Literal wording
Is a person's mind a notebook?
- Meaning and lesson
The saying excuses forgetfulness by pointing out that human memory is not a written record. A notebook keeps every entry exactly as it was set down, but a person's mind does not, so occasionally losing track of something is normal and should not be treated as a fault.
Because it is framed as a rhetorical question, with the opening word acting as a question marker rather than the pronoun 'he', the line asks the listener to agree that perfect recall is an unreasonable demand. It turns an apology into an appeal to shared human limits, inviting patience and forgiveness instead of blame for a small lapse.
- When it is used
Say it when you, or someone you are defending, have forgotten a minor detail and want to soften the slip. It fits casual, friendly exchanges and works best for small lapses, not for serious failures where a plain apology is expected.
- Register
- Colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: Do you expect a human memory to work like a written ledger?