- English translation
If you won't give anything, can't you at least offer a kind word?
- Literal wording
You have no beneficence, have you no tongue?
- Meaning and lesson
The saying sets two kinds of kindness side by side: material generosity, the sense of إحسان here rather than its theological meaning, and gracious, comforting speech, which is what "tongue" stands for, not eloquence. Someone who will not give can still be warm. Withholding both fails an easy duty as well as a costly one.
Whether heard as a statement followed by a question or as two questions, it rebukes stinginess made worse by rudeness or silence: if not one kindness, then at least the other. The speaker accepts that a gift may not come but expects a kind reply. Withholding pleasant speech, which costs nothing, is the more telling failure.
- When it is used
Use this to scold someone who refuses help and is also curt or harsh about it. It suits complaints about a stingy relative, employer, or acquaintance whose cold words make the refusal worse. It is a reproach, so it is not suited to polite or formal requests.
- Register
- colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: If you won't give anything, can't you at least offer a kind word?