- English translation
Ill-gotten gain: how could anyone even bring themselves to eat it?
- Literal wording
The forbidden thing, with what is it eaten?
- Meaning and lesson
The saying is a rhetorical question that recoils from the idea of consuming anything obtained unlawfully. Here ḥarām means ill-gotten wealth or livelihood, not forbidden foods. It treats such gain as so repugnant that a person should be unable to bring it to their mouth at all; it expects no real answer.
In practice it works as a moral rebuke aimed at people who profit through theft, fraud, or other illicit dealings. Here "eating" means living off the proceeds broadly. The speaker expresses astonishment that anyone could comfortably enjoy what was wrongfully taken, implying that honest people would find such benefit sickening rather than satisfying.
- When it is used
Say it to condemn someone who lives off dishonest earnings, or to explain why you refuse money, food, or favors of doubtful origin. It carries moral reproach and a note of disgust, so it suits pointed criticism rather than light teasing.
- Register
- colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: Ill-gotten gain: how could anyone even bring themselves to eat it?