- English translation
Like a goose, all tenderness and no milk.
- Literal wording
Like the goose: tenderness without a breast.
- Meaning and lesson
The image is a mother goose hovering over her goslings with plenty of tenderness, yet as a bird she has no breast to nurse them. Her care is real in feeling but brings them no nourishment, and the proverb rests on that contrast between visible affection and missing substance.
Applied to people, the saying targets someone known for kind words, sympathy, or fine promises who never actually provides anything. It points out that expressions of caring cost little and cannot replace concrete help. Its criticism falls on that gap, not on geese or mothers.
- When it is used
Use this to tease or criticize someone who is generous with sympathy, praise, or promises but never offers real help, money, or favors. It suits informal talk about friends, relatives, or patrons whose kindness stays only verbal.
- Register
- colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: Like a goose, all tenderness and no milk.