ProverbHub
Arabic · Arabic scriptProverb: Verified

«نَطَرِتْ عَلَى بْتَاعِ الْمَلْحْ غَنَّى بْتَاعِ الْقُلْقَاسْ، قَالْ لُهْ: أَهِي جَتْ عَلَى نَاسْ نَاسْ»

Meanings

Each meaning is reviewed on its own.

Meaning: Verified
English translation

Rain fell on the salt man, and the taro man began to sing. The salt man said to him, 'So it came for some people and not for others.'

Literal wording

It rained on the salt man; the taro man sang. He said to him: 'Well, it came upon people [and] people.'

Meaning and lesson

The same event can bless one person and ruin another. A shower that spoils one man's salt makes another man's taro thrive, so one rainfall brings joy to one neighbor and loss to the next. Fortune does not land evenly; it favors whoever needs what it happens to bring.

In the scene, the man whose salt was spoiled answers the taro man's singing by noting that the rain came for some people and not for others. The saying can point out to someone celebrating that the circumstance behind their gain has brought harm to another.

When it is used

Use when one event clearly helps one party while hurting another, especially when the party who benefits is celebrating openly. It can be voiced by the one who lost out or by an observer commenting on how unevenly a shared circumstance falls.

Register
colloquial
Cite or copy proverb