- English translation
True knowledge is carried in the mind, not on the written page.
- Literal wording
Knowledge is in the breasts, not in the lines.
- Meaning and lesson
The saying holds that real knowledge lives inside a person, figuratively in the heart and mind, held in memory and understanding, rather than sitting on a page. Learning counts only once it has been absorbed and can be drawn on without needing to consult a written record.
It also carries a quiet warning. Owning books, notes, or written texts does not make someone learned. A person who merely possesses writings, without having taken their content to heart, cannot honestly claim the knowledge those pages hold. The point is not to dismiss writing, but to insist that its content be absorbed.
- When it is used
Suited to moments praising someone who has truly absorbed a subject, or gently challenging a person who relies on notes, books, or recorded material without having actually mastered what they contain.
- Register
- Colloquial Arabic, marked by the dialectal negator موش
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: True knowledge is carried in the mind, not on the written page.