- English translation
Who would ever dare claim there's a mule inside the jug?
- Literal wording
Would anyone say: the mule is in the pitcher?
- Meaning and lesson
The saying pictures someone announcing that a mule sits inside a pitcher. The image is so plainly impossible that no listener could accept it. Posed as a rhetorical question that seeks no answer, it implies that such a statement is unthinkable and that no one would have the nerve to say it aloud.
More broadly, the proverb holds that a sensible person will not put forward a claim whose falsehood is obvious at a glance. A lie can only succeed if it is believable. Asserting the absurd invites ridicule and costs the speaker credibility, so even a deceiver has limits.
- When it is used
Use it to dismiss a claim so obviously impossible that stating it would expose the speaker as a liar or a fool. It works as a sarcastic question aimed at someone stretching the truth, or as a reminder that some falsehoods are too blatant to attempt.
- Register
- colloquial
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: Who would ever dare claim there's a mule inside the jug?