ProverbHub
Arabic · Arabic scriptProverb: Verified

«هِيَّ تِحْلِبِ الَّا لَمَّا يْكُونْ لَهَا بَو؟»

Meanings

Each meaning is reviewed on its own.

Meaning: Verified
English translation

Would that cow ever let down her milk without a calf-skin to coax her?

Literal wording

Will she give milk unless she has a stuffed calf-hide?

Meaning and lesson

The image comes from dairy herding. A cow often withholds her milk unless reminded of her calf, so herders kept a calf's hide stuffed with straw nearby, not a living calf, to coax the flow. The rhetorical question expects the answer no: she would not yield milk without that prop.

Applied to people, it describes someone whose generosity or effort has to be set off by an outside trigger. Such a person waits for a reason, a reward, or a stirring of feeling before they give or act. The remark can sound wry, resigned, or mildly scornful.

When it is used

Said of someone who will not give, help, or work unless a motive is placed in front of them, such as a reward, a pressing need, or an emotional pull. It can be dry or reproachful, and applied to a person it may sound like criticism of their character.

Register
Colloquial Arabic, phrased as a rhetorical question
Cite or copy proverb