- English translation
Would that cow ever let down her milk without a calf-skin to coax her?
- Literal wording
Will she give milk unless she has a stuffed calf-hide?
- Meaning and lesson
The image comes from dairy herding. A cow often withholds her milk unless reminded of her calf, so herders kept a calf's hide stuffed with straw nearby, not a living calf, to coax the flow. The rhetorical question expects the answer no: she would not yield milk without that prop.
Applied to people, it describes someone whose generosity or effort has to be set off by an outside trigger. Such a person waits for a reason, a reward, or a stirring of feeling before they give or act. The remark can sound wry, resigned, or mildly scornful.
- When it is used
Said of someone who will not give, help, or work unless a motive is placed in front of them, such as a reward, a pressing need, or an emotional pull. It can be dry or reproachful, and applied to a person it may sound like criticism of their character.
- Register
- Colloquial Arabic, phrased as a rhetorical question
Cite or copy proverb
How this record reached us: Editorially sourced.
Report an issue with this meaning: Would that cow ever let down her milk without a calf-skin to coax her?